Women Don't Ask

The Broken Rung Problem Holding Women Back from Management

The gender gap in leadership doesn't start at the top—it starts at the very first promotion. "The broken rung" explains why women fall behind early, and why fixing it is a management-design problem, not a morale one.

The Broken Rung Problem Holding Women Back from Management

Ask a room full of HR directors where the gender gap in leadership actually starts, and you'll usually hear the same answer: the top. The corner office, the C-suite, the board. Keep digging, though, and the story changes. The most damaging drop-off happens far earlier — at the very first step from individual contributor to manager. That gap has a name now: the broken rung.

I remember the first time it clicked for me. I was sitting in a calibration meeting, the kind where managers argue over who gets promoted. A woman on my team had shipped more than anyone else in her group that year. When her name came up, someone said she was "not quite ready for the next level." Nobody could point to a specific failure. It was a feeling. Six months later she left the company. I've thought about that meeting more than any spreadsheet I've ever built.

Key Takeaways

  • The broken rung describes the first promotion gap — the step from entry level to manager — where women fall behind men disproportionately, and the deficit compounds at every level above it.
  • It's different from the glass ceiling: the ceiling blocks people already near the top, the broken rung blocks them before they've climbed at all.
  • Bias in promotion decisions is rarely loud. It shows up as "not ready yet," vague concerns, and a preference for people who already look like the last person who held the job.
  • Fixing it is a management-design problem, not a morale problem. Clear criteria, named sponsors, and tracking promotion rates by gender at each level do more than any awareness campaign.
  • You don't need permission to build your own ladder — sponsor relationships and lateral moves can bypass a broken rung, but only if you know that's what you're doing.

What is the broken rung theory — and why it matters more than the glass ceiling

The broken rung theory says that the biggest obstacle to women reaching management isn't a barrier at the top. It's the very first promotion. When you compare men and women at the entry level, men are promoted into their first management role at a notably higher rate. The gap is small enough to look like noise in any single team. Multiply it across thousands of teams and a decade of careers, and it becomes the reason the leadership pipeline thins out long before anyone reaches the executive floor.

LeanIn.Org and McKinsey gave the idea its name in their Women in the Workplace research, drawing on years of pipeline data across hundreds of companies. The finding was blunt: for every 100 men promoted to manager, only around 81 women were. Later editions moved the number a little, but the shape of the gap held. And the gap is worst for women of color, who are promoted into management at even lower rates than white women.

Broken rung vs glass ceiling: what's the actual difference?

The glass ceiling is a barrier you hit when you're already close to the top. You've made it through management, through director, through VP — and then the next step stalls. It's real, and it still exists.

The broken rung sits underneath all of that. It's the first step that never happens. One metaphor is about altitude. The other is about the ladder itself.

Broken rungGlass ceiling
Where it hitsEntry level → first management roleSenior leadership → executive/board
Who it affects mostEarly-career women, especially women of colorWomen already in senior roles
How it shows upFewer promotions, "not ready yet" feedback, thinner sponsorshipFewer C-suite and board seats, slower advancement at the top
Why it's harder to seeEach individual case looks like a judgment callIt's visible in org charts
What fixes itClear promotion criteria, tracked promotion rates by genderSuccession planning, board-level accountability

Here's the thing that took me too long to internalize: fixing the ceiling without fixing the rung is like widening the top of a funnel while narrowing the bottom. The math doesn't work.

Why the first promotion breaks — and what's actually happening in the room

Nobody sends a memo saying "don't promote women." The bias is more subtle than that, and that's exactly why it survives.

The "not ready yet" problem

When managers evaluate someone for their first management role, they're not scoring a spreadsheet. They're making a judgment about potential. And potential is where bias lives, because it's unobservable and therefore easy to fill with assumptions. A man who's confident gets read as "high potential." A woman with the same track record gets read as "strong individual contributor, maybe not a leader." Same evidence, different story.

The most common phrasing is some version of "she needs more time." I've heard it said about people who had already been in the role for two years longer than the men promoted ahead of them.

The thinner tie-breaker

Promotions are rarely decided on objective metrics alone. There's usually a tie-breaker, and the tie-breaker is often familiarity. Who has the sponsor who'll go to bat in the room? Who has already worked closely with the person making the call? If the decision-makers are mostly men, and their informal networks are mostly men, the tie-breaker goes to the men. Not out of malice. Out of pattern recognition, which is another word for bias.

What I got wrong about this for years

Early in my career I assumed the fix was mentorship. Pair women with senior mentors, the thinking went, and they'd get the guidance they needed. What I learned — slowly, by watching programs like that produce almost nothing measurable — is that mentorship is not the lever. Sponsorship is. A mentor tells you how to navigate the system. A sponsor spends their own credibility getting you into the room. And most companies have plenty of mentors and almost no sponsors, especially for early-career women.

What are the barriers preventing women from reaching leadership positions?

If the broken rung is the first barrier, it isn't the only one. Think of it as the first in a chain, where each link makes the next one harder.

  • Promotion bias at the first step — the "not quite ready" dynamic above, which filters women out before they've had a chance to prove themselves as managers.
  • Sponsorship gaps — men tend to be sponsored more actively by senior leaders, and those relationships translate directly into advancement opportunities.
  • Unpaid labor at home — caregiving responsibilities still fall disproportionately on women, and they intersect with the moments when career advancement tends to accelerate. The result is a timing mismatch, not a capability gap.
  • Double standards in how leadership is read — assertiveness in a man can read as "leadership material"; the same behavior in a woman can read as something else entirely.
  • The compounding deficit — every year a woman isn't promoted into management, she's further behind when the next rung comes up.

What makes the chain so hard to break is that it's self-reinforcing. Each barrier feeds the next. The women who make it through tend to be exceptional, which creates a false impression that the system is working fine.

What are the biases against women in leadership?

The most documented ones cluster around two things: how competence is judged, and how personality is read.

On competence, the bias is about presumed potential. Women are often held to a higher bar for the same result, and given credit more slowly for the same achievement. On personality, the bias is about the double bind: behavior that would be seen as appropriately decisive in a man can be seen as difficult in a woman, while the softer behavior that avoids that label reads as insufficiently leadership-ready. It's a trap in both directions, and recognizing it is the first step to not stepping in it.

There's a third bias that gets less airtime. It's the likability penalty — the tendency for evaluations to quietly factor in how pleasant someone is to work with, in a way that's unevenly applied.

How does the glass ceiling affect women, and how is it different from what comes before

The glass ceiling is what most people think of when they hear about the gender gap in leadership. It's real, and it deserves attention. But it's most visible at the senior levels, where the numbers are small and the disparities are easier to see in an org chart.

The people affected by the ceiling are, by definition, the survivors of the rung. They've already navigated the earlier filters. If you only look at the ceiling, you're studying the people who made it through — which is exactly the population least representative of the broader problem.

This is the trap I see in a lot of well-meaning DEI reporting: the numbers look decent at the director level, so the company concludes it's doing well. Then you look one level down and the pipeline has already thinned out, and the discrepancy is explained away as "pipeline issues." The pipeline isn't the problem. The promotions are.

How to fix the broken rung — at the company level and at the personal level

There's a version of this advice that says "change the culture." That's true and it's also useless, because culture is downstream of decisions. So let's talk about the decisions.

If you're the one making promotion decisions

  1. Make promotion criteria explicit. If the criteria are vague, the decision defaults to gut feel, and gut feel has a bias problem.
  2. Track promotion rates by gender and level. Not as a yearly diversity report — as a monthly operational metric that someone looks at. You can't fix what you don't measure at the level where it happens.
  3. Separate the "ready" question from the "potential" question. If someone has met the criteria, they're ready. The question of whether they're "ready for the next level after that" is a distraction.
  4. Count the sponsorships. Ask your senior leaders which early-career people they're actively advocating for. If the list is all men, you've found your broken rung.

If you're the one climbing the ladder

First, recognize that a broken rung doesn't mean your career is broken. It means the system is. That distinction matters, because it tells you where to aim your energy.

The highest-leverage move I've seen work — for myself and for people I've coached — is to stop waiting for the promotion and start building the evidence trail and the sponsorship simultaneously. Find one person senior enough to have real influence, and make it easy for them to advocate for you by being specific about what you want and what you've delivered. Vague ambition is hard to sponsor. A concrete ask with a track record attached is not.

Second: lateral moves that broaden your scope often do more for your promotion odds than staying put and hoping. A move into a team with more visibility, or a role that touches revenue, can reset how you're read in the next calibration.

And third: if you're in a company where the rung has been broken for years and nothing is being done about it, the honest answer is that some companies aren't worth your patience. I've seen people spend three years waiting for a promotion that was never going to come from a manager who didn't see them. Leaving was the best thing they ever did.

The question that lingers

The broken rung isn't a mystery. We know where it is, we know roughly how wide it is, and we know it compounds. The uncomfortable part isn't the diagnosis. It's that fixing it requires the people currently in power — the ones who make promotion decisions — to scrutinize their own judgment calls, one meeting at a time, for years. That's slow, unglamorous work with no ribbon-cutting.

The question I keep returning to isn't whether companies can fix it. Plenty can. It's whether they'll do the arithmetic that makes the case impossible to ignore: every woman who leaves because she never got the first step is a manager you won't have in five years, and a leader you won't have in ten. The cost of the broken rung isn't paid by the women who leave. It's paid by the organizations that never noticed them.

Elliot Lockhart

Elliot Lockhart

Elliot Lockhart is a leadership advisor and author who helps organizations build inclusive workplaces where everyone can advance. Drawing on years of experience in management development, he specializes in workplace leadership, career development for women, and inclusive management practices. His practical, evidence-based approach has made him a trusted voice for leaders seeking to create fair and effective teams.

See all articles →

Related articles